Sketchy new trend – hiring fake online review writers

September 8, 2011

spotting fake reviews online Sketchy new trend   hiring fake online review writers

Unethical but seemingly common practice

Realtor reviews and testimonials have always been riddled with fakes- agents who write their own testimonials with fake accolades, touting their “integrity” and “superior service” and the like. Those inside the industry can typically spot a fake when we see the full name of the brokerage in the review (consumers typically use an agent’s name or a shortened version of the brokerage name, not Joe Bob Williams Team Realty International LLC Number One), or unnatural language that looks eerily like a real estate website template (“my number one agent provided top notch real estate negotiations in real estate transactions”).

Have consumers become hip to the sketchy reviews written by Realtors on their own sites and printed in their collateral? Most likely, yes. The good news is that the rise of social networking is rapidly changing the review methods and reviews left are tied to a person and their real identity, for example, on Facebook or Yelp. Consumers are more willing to be honest and open if they have to legitimize a review with their true identity, plus this makes it more difficult for the fake Realtor reviews of yesteryear to rise to the top. Consumers have a nose for fake, overly-floral reviews and expect natural language.

Advertise at AG

The new sketchy trend is for businesses (not just Realtors) to hire fake online review writers. Cruise Craigslist in your city, and you’ll see Realtors, retailers, plumbers and lenders paying $5 to $10 for a legitimate user to give them a review, so long as that user has an active Yelp account or a similar account. This gets businesses around having to make fake accounts and keep them active, instead, just pay a few bucks for a fake review. The truth is, the reviews look real, are written in natural language and are by a legitimate person, not “Thomas H. of Dallas, Texas” who has no bio or picture.

Picking up deceptive cues online

Not only is hiring fake review writers unethical, it sullies the entire review process. There is no way to tell the full extent of how many reviews online on real users’ accounts are fake, but Cornell University has studied the legitimacy of online reviews and has spotted some deceptive indicators as published in the New York Times, with human subjects unable to tell real reviews from fake reviews.

fake web reviews Sketchy new trend   hiring fake online review writers

The above review doesn’t start off as strongly deceptive and appears to be in relatively natural language, but the repetition of these cues made for an obvious pattern to the Cornell researchers. Immediately, we were dubious and opened our own Yelp accounts and were shocked that none of us had started a single review with “my [spouse] and I,” even though we would say that out loud naturally. We also rarely used the actual business’ name in the reviews and didn’t use “I” and “me” very frequently (although some of us are very enthusiastic and used exclamation marks frequently, but mostly in negative reviews).

We’ll see this trend of paid reviews for people looking to make a quick buck in a down market, and Realtors are already using and will undoubtedly increase use of these willing reviewers, making for a repeat of history where agents are painted as being “number one,” having “impeccable integrity” and “superior service,” along with the new patterns in fake web reviews as discovered by Cornell researchers.

AGBeat Chief Operating Officer: Lani, named 100 Most Influential, as well as 12 Most Influential Women in Blogging, Bashh Founder, Out and about in Austin A Lister, is a business and tech writer and startup consultant hailing from the great state of Texas in the city of Austin. As a digital native, Lani is immersed not only in advanced technologies and new media, but is also a stats nerd often buried in piles of reports. Lani is a proven leader, thoughtful speaker, and vested partner at AGBeat.


  1. Pingback: Rebekah Radice

  2. Pingback: Real Estate Ninja

  3. Pingback: UGMS

  4. Pingback: KW Hampton Roads

  5. Pingback: kristin terry

  6. Pingback: RealEstate Babble

  7. Pingback: Thad Schell

  8. Pingback: Brandon Kekich

  9. Someone should look into the bloggers who buy their blogs. Many on Active rain I suspect.

  10. This is an old problem. Reviews are just advertising

  11. Pingback: Ben Harris

  12. Pingback: Steve Parker

  13. My wife and I enjoyed reading this article very much. The writing was clear and provocative. The perspective on our industry was insightful. This is a disturbing trend! Learning how to spot a fake is really useful and I hope we get a chance to use it. AgentGenius features the best and brightest, you can't go wrong subscribing here.

    • Jay, you win bonus points, that was the PERFECT comment! lol

      • Glad you enjoyed it. Couldn't resist.

        • Dammit, Jay, You beat me too it! I just found the article today and I was planning on leaving a comment like yours! Curses!

  14. Pingback:

  15. Pingback: James K Barath, CMPS

  16. I read your story with great interest. This is exactly why Realtor Reviews must be done in a closed systems (where only real customers, and in our case every actual customer, is offered the opportunity to review the agent they worked with), vs. an open system (where anyone can complete a review, be it grandma, a competitor or paid reviewer). I wanted to make sure you were aware of and our soon to be launched national site, This is our only business and we are truly helping the industry raise the bar in terms of customer service. Thank you!

  17. Love the yelp reviews! Just started to circulate those. I think its easier to get a video of the client in a relaxed environment. Their own home.

    Just ask questions about their shopping adventure and treatment?

    David Pylyp
    Accredited Senior Agent Living in Toronto

  18. Thank you for taking to the time to point this issue out. It's obvious something odd is going on when every agent on zillow has 5 star ratings.

  19. Pingback: Russ Bergeron

  20. Pingback: AgentGenius

  21. Pingback: Kimberly Brooks

  22. Pingback: Mark Chupeyda

  23. Pingback: Mark Chupeyda

  24. Pingback: newmedialab

  25. Pingback: AgentGenius

  26. Pingback: AmberAusten

  27. Pingback: Kristi

  28. Pingback: Kristi

  29. Pingback: Imelda Dulcich PR

  30. Pingback: Market Leader

  31. Pingback: Steve NeSmith

  32. Pingback: Mark Chupeyda

  33. I can't imagine anyone selecting real estate representation based on reviews.

    Doctors: "My doctor is the best cutter around! REALLY sharp scalpels!"
    Accountants: "My CPA added numbers WAY better than the last guy!"
    Lawyers: awe… never-mind…

  34. Pingback: ABoR REALTORS®

  35. Pingback: AgentGenius

  36. Pingback: Chris Apple

  37. Pingback: Skip Cody

  38. Pingback: Will Amorin

  39. Pingback: David Pylyp

  40. Pingback: Century 21 Learning

  41. Pingback: Victor Lund

  42. Pingback: John (B.C.) Williams

  43. Pingback: Erica Lawrence REVA

  44. Pingback: Referral Agreement

  45. Pingback: Agent Ken

  46. Pingback: Brooke Wolford

  47. Pingback: Tim Wolf

  48. Pingback: Chance Brown, SFR

  49. Pingback: AgentGenius

  50. Pingback: Judy Graff

  51. Pingback: Michael S. Cole

  52. Pingback: Michael S. Cole

  53. Pingback: Amber Cook

  54. Pingback: Dynamic Robert

  55. Pingback: Jill McGowan

  56. Pingback:

  57. Pingback: Alyssa Abkowitz

  58. Pingback: Andy Theobald

  59. Pingback: @TXFoundationRpr

  60. Pingback: Superior Foundations

  61. Pingback: AgentGenius

  62. Pingback: FixCourse

  63. Pingback: Brad Smith

  64. Pingback: Max Berdowski

  65. Pingback: Spotting Fake Consumer Reviews - Senkai Labs Blog

  66. Pingback: Red flags in emails that reveal when someone is lying - AGBeat

Leave A Comment