Trulia’s top ten cities to buy versus rent and rent versus buy
Best cities to buy and rent
Real estate search site Trulia.com has analyzed the largest 50 cities in America, calculating the price-to-rent ratio comparing the average list price in each city with the average rent for two bedroom apartments, townhomes and condos, and naming the top 10 cities best for buying and top 10 for renting.
The analysis is based on listings on Trulia.com and took into account costs of home ownership (including “mortgage principal and interest, property taxes, hazard insurance, closing costs at time of purchase and ongoing HOA dues and private mortgage insurance, where applicable. Total costs of homeownership include an offset for the tax advantages of homeownership, including mortgage interest, property tax and closing cost deductions”) as well as costs of renting (rent as well as renter’s insurance).
According to Trulia’s Social Media Guru, Rudy Bachraty, “we did not include appreciation or depreciation. The market is too unstable to predict right now. This is the current snapshot if you were to buy or rent today.”
Top 10 cities to buy vs. rent
- Minneapolis, MN
- Arlington, TX
- Miami, FL
- Fresno, CA
- San Antonio, TX
- Mesa, AZ
- Jacksonville, FL
- Phoenix, AZ
- El Paso, TX
- Las Vegas, NV
Top 10 cities to rent vs. buy
- New York, NY
- Omaha, NE
- Seattle, WA
- Portland, OR
- San Francisco, CA
- Oklahoma City, OK
- Kansas City, MO
- San Diego, CA
- Cleveland, OH
- Dallas, TX
Why some cities beat out others
“At the peak of the real estate bubble, cities like Miami, Phoenix and Las Vegas were not affordable for many. Now the opposite is true,” said Pete Flint, co-founder and CEO of Trulia. “Home sellers in these hard hit areas are forced to lower their prices to compete with all the foreclosures on the market. As a result, these unattainable markets are so affordable it makes better financial sense to buy than rent.”
Trulia offers a rent versus buy calculator on their website (click here) and plan on publishing the rent vs. buy city rankings in the future, most likely each quarter. To download the top 50 cities comparing renting versus owning, click here.
CC Licensed image courtesy of isherwoodchris via Flickr.com.
Start spreading the news...
This article published on Thursday, June 3rd, 2010 at 10:10 pm | Contact the editor
Topics: News
About this Columnist (Full Profile)
AGBeat Editor-in-Chief: Lani, named one of Real Estate’s 100 Most Influential, as well as 12 Most Influential Women in Real Estate, is a business writer hailing from the great state of Texas in the city of Austin. As a digital native, Lani is immersed not only in advanced technologies and new media, but is also a stats nerd often burried in piles of reports. Lani is a proven leader, thoughtful speaker, and vested partner at AGBeat.
Email Lani Rosales
The Daily Hot Sheet
The AGBeat Daily is jam packed with today's news headlines, fresh and neat in your inbox- start the day ahead of the curve.
Comments (19)
Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed
Social Shares & Links Back
- Oklahoma City — Rent or Buy?:
[...] read a blog post from Lani Rosales of AgentGenius Magazine this morning titled “Trulia’s Top 10 Cities to Buy vs Rent and Rent vs Buy”. I was shocked to see Oklahoma City listed as number 6 on the list of best cities to rent versus [...]
- Isabel A. Fontaneau:
RT @CB_Florida: Trulia’s top ten cities to buy versus rent and rent versus buy (via @LaniAR): http://ht.ly/1Ue8o (2 FL cities best to bu …
- United Country :
Trulia’s top ten cities to buy versus rent and rent versus buy (via @agentgenius): http://bit.ly/9NhkCs // Interesting list!
- AgentGenius:
#agnow [...] read a blog post from Lani Rosales of AgentGenius Magazine this morning titled “Trulia’s Top 10 Ci… http://bit.ly/9BkB3q
- BHG Real Estate:
Trulia’s top ten cities to buy versus rent and rent versus buy (Agent Genius) http://ow.ly/1UuaO
- The Ten Best in RE.net This Week: June 5, 2010 Edition:
[...] 4 ) Should you buy or should you rent? A lot of that is going to depend on the market you live in. Here is a list of Trulia’s top ten cities to buy versus rent and rent versus buy. [...]
- Nicholas Rapisardi:
@d_dowen @EconBizFin http://bit.ly/9Klszx yeah BP is charging Jesus $ 2.87 9/10 for every gallon of gulf oil no thanks to this GIANT spill!
- optimacondosAZ:
RT @BHGRealEstate: Trulia’s top ten cities to buy versus rent and rent versus buy (Agent Genius) http://ow.ly/1UuaO
- Optima:
RT @BHGRealEstate: Trulia’s top ten cities to buy versus rent and rent versus buy (Agent Genius) http://ow.ly/1UuaO
- AgentGenius:
#agnow [...] 4 ) Should you buy or should you rent? A lot of that is going to depend on the market you live in. Her… http://bit.ly/9BkB3q
- Susan Lloyd:
Trulia's top-10 cities in which to rent vs. buy and buy vs. rent http://ow.ly/1V0xB #housingmarket
- AgentGenius:
#agnow San Diego homes are at their most affordable prices in decades, yet the research says rent instead of buy? … http://bit.ly/9BkB3q
- Nicole Johnsrud:
Minneapolis #1 best place to buy vs rent!! Low interest rates, lots of choices-why not! http://ow.ly/2IltK
Benn Rosales
Conal Campbell
Elijah May
Lani Rosales
Tara Steele
Marti Trewe
Charlene Jimenez
OK, Dallas in the top 10 of Rent vs Buy . . . If that is truly comparing 2 bedroom apartments, townhomes and condos, and if it is only in Dallas, as in near Downtown Dallas, then maybe this dataset is reliable. If it is the entire market for the Dallas Area residential market, then I submit this dataset is suspect at best.
I can see markets like Fresno, Miami, Mesa and Phoenix, AZ in the buy vs rent category as they were obviously “pounded” the last few years. But, Dallas? Dalas has held its ground fairly well during the downturn.
It would be great if Trulia would qualify their market data for improved granularity . . .
Ditto what Greg said at the end of his comments. I’m not a big fan of Trulia or Zillow “reports.” Zillow’s own explanation of their “Zestimates” proposes that their “A” data properties only have a 7.5% margin of error. Anywhoo, I’m surprised there aren’t more Southern locales on the list with prices the way they are in the Atlanta area.
I personally thought Dallas would be higher in the rankings regarding rent vs buy.
San Diego homes are at their most affordable prices in decades, yet the research says rent instead of buy? I guess there will be a lot of eternal renters who follow that advice.
Exactly how does “Trulia” know?
I use recent and REAL rental and sales examples from Miami Beach’s waterfront condo buildings (The Continuum, The Murano Grande, Icon South Beach, The Bentley Bay, and The Floridian) to analyze South Beach’s rent vs. Buy market Index as outlined by Trulia.
thekleerteam.com/blog/2010/10/Is-The-Rent-vs-Buy-Index-Relevant-for-Miami-Beach-Homes-and-Condos-.htm