Freddie Mac warns of the top four short sale fraud schemes

August 23, 2011
684 Views
fraud Freddie Mac warns of the top four short sale fraud schemes

Portrait of a fraud, image by Don Hankins.

Freddie Mac sends out warnings

With short sale fraud on the rise, Freddie Mac has been getting a high volume of calls, so they are setting out to communicate with Realtor associations as well as individual agents about these fraudulent activities.

With 6.5 million Americans more than 30 days delinquent on their mortgage payments and recent reports that delinquencies rose in the second quarter of 2011, and Freddie Mac saying the volume of short sales they have processed in the first half of 2011 is up 31 percent over the first half of 2010, it is highly likely that fraudulent activity will increase as short sales and foreclosures remain a target.

Rigging sales and illegal flipping

Freddie Mac officials have noted that the rising fraud sometimes involves a failure on the Realtor’s part to disclose other parties involved in a transaction and that these Realtors “rig sales” at a low price and hide better offers from the distressed homeowner and even from Freddie Mac.



Advertise at AG

“Then, after the house is sold, the fraudster can flip it a few hours later for the better price and walk away with the profitable difference,” said Freddie Mac VP, Shelley Poland and Fraud Investigations Associate Director Robert Hagberg on Freddie Mac’s blog.

“By concealing the higher offer, short sale fraud worsens losses to home sellers, Freddie Mac, and taxpayers. It also throws another wrench into the housing recovery by undermining the trust and transparency at the core of any real estate transaction,” they continued.

Investigating the fraudulent acts

Freddie Mac has a unit dedicated to short sales fraud which is now the top priority of Director Hagberg’s unit. Poland and Hagberg said that the unit has “also added the perpetrators to our Exclusionary List – firms and individuals barred from conducting business with Freddie Mac – and worked with law enforcement agencies to prosecute them.”

The top four fraudulent trends

Manipulation is the name of the game as Freddie Mac notes Realtors involved in fraud manipulate bids, manipulate broker price opinions, manipulate flipping schemes and manipulate settlement statements.

As the unit investigated the fraud, specific trends emerged such as agents discouraging legitimate bids by putting in false offers on a property and making sure their accomplices get the property for a predetermined low bid. Other agents manipulate the listing price to make overstating repair costs to obtain an artificially low broker price opinion in order to manipulate the listing price.

Also on the rise is dirty flipping schemes wherein an agent buys a short sale from Freddie (or the banks) by using falsified loan documents and title documents, then selling the property to a legitimate buyer at a higher price, often within hours of closing.

Freddie Mac warns that some are altering the HUD-1 settlement statement to “skim away net proceeds” from the sale into their own pocket.

Dealing with short sale fraud

In addition to their Exclusionary List, Freddie Mac now requires all parties in any short sale to sign an affidavit, “attesting that it is a true arms-length transaction,” thus strengthening Freddie’s “legal path.”

“There are many conscientious real estate professionals who want to do the right thing. We often receive calls in our servicing, quality control, fraud investigation, outreach, and HomeSteps divisions from real estate agents who know they’ve seen something inappropriate and won’t look the other way,” the executives said. “They understand that real estate fraud turns a shortsighted profit at the cost of the public’s long-term confidence in homeownership and the housing industry.”

Tara Steele is the News Director at AgentGenius, covering real estate news, technology news and everything in between. If you'd like to reach Tara with a question, comment, press release or hot news tip, she frequently checks her email, simply click the link below.


  • Pingback: Thad Schell

  • Pingback: RealEstate Babble

  • Pingback: UGMS

  • Pingback: Real Estate Ninja

  • Pingback: kristin terry

  • Pingback: KW Hampton Roads

  • Pingback: Rebekah Radice

  • Pingback: Brandon Kekich

  • Pingback: Rene Burchell

  • Pingback: Rene Burchell

  • http://www.lizbenitez.com Liz Benitez

    It is ridiculous!! How is our market supposed to recover when there are agents undermining it left and right?

  • Pingback: Mark Bowen

  • Pingback: JWL Consulting

  • Pingback: Bob Falter PhD GRI

  • Pingback: James K Barath, CMPS

  • Pingback: WelcomeHomeNWI.com

  • Pingback: Mark McHugh

  • Pingback: BairdWarner NWOffice

  • Pingback: Kerry Thornhill

  • Pingback: Jenna Devers

  • Pingback: CEA

  • Pingback: Stewart Fairfax

  • Pingback: Jeff Eraca

  • Pingback: Market Leader

  • Pingback: Lois de Armas

  • Pingback: Ben Benjamin

  • Pingback: My Outdesk, Inc.

  • Pingback: TitleCore

  • Pingback: TitleCore

  • Pingback: James Parker - EBA

  • Pingback: OnlineEd

  • Pingback: Portland Real Estate

  • Pingback: Kai Andersen

  • Pingback: My Outdesk, Inc.

  • Pingback: sedonahome

  • Pingback: A Monteferrante

  • Pingback: Teresa Kahler

  • William Gassett, JR

    This is another attempt by Freddie Mac to control the market and CREATE LAW.
    Let's go through this a bit.

    1 – “rig sales” at a low price and hide better offers from the distressed homeowner and even from Freddie Mac." – Agents submit ONE OFFER at a time. If the first offer is accepted and it's low, I HAVE NO DUTY so submit the higher offer. This is CRAZY. Do you know the lawsuits from sellers and buyers I would face if I just start submitting ALL OFFERS to Freddie Mac?? How EXACTLY are agents RIGGING sales?

    2 – “Then, after the house is sold, the fraudster can flip it a few hours later for the better price and walk away with the profitable difference,” – Ok ONCE I OWN A HOUSE, I should be able to do what I want with it right? there was no straw buyer, the INVESTOR TOOK TITLE. Investors aren't in business to LOSE MONEY?? They are cleaning the GLUT of homes on the market. My house, my profit.

    3 – "By concealing the higher offer, short sale fraud worsens losses to home sellers, Freddie Mac, and taxpayers. It also throws another wrench into the housing recovery by undermining the trust and transparency at the core of any real estate transaction,” – AGAIN as an agent I can only submit more than one contract at a time. EVERYTHING AFTER THAT FIRST OFFER GOES IN BACK UP POSITION and IT'S NOT FREDDIE MAC'S business at that point. If they DENY the first short sale then I can submit the back up offer whether it's higher or lower. Again, legitimate FLIP investors DISCLOSE they are marketing and reselling the property immediately for profit. At the time they submit the contract they have NO IDEA if there is a higher offer or not. Transparency. They TELL the servicer they are selling immediately for profit. HOW IS TELLING A LENDER THAT FRAUD?

    How does it worsen losses to sellers? They can't get money for the short sale? So long as there is a full deficiency release, HOW does an investor offer WORSEN LOSSES. It doesn't matter if an investor makes the offer or suzie and joe smith making the same offer. Lenders follow INvESTOR GUIDELINES. They need minimum nets and it makes no difference if the offer comes from an investor or Joe and Suzie Smith

    3-"Manipulation is the name of the game as Freddie Mac notes Realtors involved in fraud manipulate bids, manipulate broker price opinions, manipulate flipping schemes and manipulate settlement statements." How exactly does a Realtor MANIPULATE a BPO? Isn't the BPO agent HIRED BY THE LENDER? Is the Realtor STEALING the BPO info and submitting it to Freddie and pretending to be the BPO agent???? C'mon Freddie, we know you want to keep most of the money possible, but get real.

    It's perfectly LEGAL to buy and sell property EVEN ON THE SAME DAY so long as it was disclosed in the contract. I GET that Freddie wants to preserve the most money possible, but STOP driving fear into home sellers and Realtors by publishing information that is EXTREMELY misleading.